Gwen and P!nk Cut From "Idol Gives Back"

31. Gwen Stefani is an ugly flat chested chick who has no talent the red lipstick and ugly blonde hair dont help her ugly looks either. And she has the ugliest body ever Kate Hudson looks good with a flat chest but Gwen is ugly.

Posted at 7:25PM on Apr 26th 2007 by chochie

32. wow, maybe if they had shown gwen i wouldnt have gotten bored and stopped watching in the middle. stop trying to shove el divo down our throats! we dont want them!! the performances were a bore.

Posted at 7:30PM on Apr 26th 2007 by bean1217

33. THEY CUT CONSTANTINE MAROULIS TOO!

Constantine was the best thing to ever come out of idol and he taped a piece for them to used on the show. Once again the powers that be at American Idol chose to disrespect Constantine by cutting his part from the show.

Constantine has promoted AI in every sound bite and press junket he has done for them. And once again AI slaps him in the face.

Why can't they give this handsome and talented man a break? Has he not broken his back enough for you?

Posted at 8:06PM on Apr 26th 2007 by Rori

34. With those looks on their faces, I understand why they were left out!

Posted at 8:25PM on Apr 26th 2007 by Me,Myself,& I

35. American Idol has cheapened itself by begging for donations, no matter how worthy the cause.
Idol is supposed to be entertainment - an escape - not a TELETHON!!!

Posted at 5:14PM on Apr 27th 2007 by Cari

36. KELLY CLARKSTON DIDN'T SOUND GOOD AT ALL, AND HER DRESS WAS SOOOO FRUMPYY,,,,,,,DIDN'T SHE KNOW SHE KNOW SHE WAS GOING TO BE ON T.V?

Posted at 11:17PM on Apr 28th 2007 by hilda

37. I really hate it when filthy rich celebrities beg the general public for money. They could have found 30 celebrities to give 1 million each.. which seems like a ton to us but, is the equivalent of about $100 to a hard working family. I know I probably seem quite cynical but, I was really disappointed in the show. They had hyped it up as being the best thing ever.. and then when all was said and done I felt like we the viewer just got scammed. What they did to Jordin was possibly the meanest thing I have ever seen!! It was all set up to make it seem like her or Melinda would be leaving when Ryan talked about how "shocking" the results were going to be!! It seemed like a ploy to keep the veiwers tuned in.. and clearly they felt they needed the ploy because the show itself was rather dull.
I do commend the effort but, what would have been wayyy more interesting and probably better received would have been to have Ex-Idol contestants show up and perform.. solo, and together and maybe let everyone know what they have been up to. It would have seemed more sincere for them to request money.. not a bunch of pampered celebs.

Posted at 11:30PM on Apr 26th 2007 by KaraL

38. How could Idol have a show like that without Clay and Rueben.

Posted at 11:58PM on Apr 26th 2007 by greg

39. Love how they take bad pics...................Gwen is BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!

Posted at 10:22AM on Apr 27th 2007 by me

40. gwen i like you but your almost 40 why you still wearing your make up like if your still in your 20s?

Posted at 5:54PM on Apr 27th 2007 by jessica

41. I agree with all those who ask why do rich celebrities beg the working class for $10??? C'mon, Madonna, Simon, Ellen, Nigel Lithgo, even Ryan Seacrest, etc...HOW MUCH DID U GIVE??????? They earn huge amounts of $$$ and don't pay for their clothes, food, hotels, NOTHING! Everyone gives them freebies, let them donate. The height of hyposcrisy was Exxon Mobil's sponsorship! Ha, how much are you paying for gas people??? WAKE UP AMERICA!!!

Posted at 3:06AM on Apr 27th 2007 by Its a SCAM

42. Aren't you sick of the Hollyweird Elite telling you how to make the world better? We, the average person should conserve, recycle, go hybrid, go green, cut back, give back and pay outrageous prices to see these clowns in movies and hear them on their CD. I say, put your money where your mouth is.....some of these artist make MILLIONS a year - how about you donate 3 or 4 % of your disposable income and then stop jet setting around the world telling people how concerned and "real" you are. I ain't buying it - how are you conserving, how are you cutting back? We have access to your "riders" we see how overendulged you are.

Posted at 7:56AM on Apr 27th 2007 by Paul

43. i watched AI just to see P!nk and Gwen. That sux. the elvis/celine theng was ok not the best. i rather have seen P!nk sing.

Posted at 8:55AM on Apr 27th 2007 by roberta

44. I have no problem with charity, but I agree totally with those comments about these rich celebs attempting to manipulate "average Jane and Joe" Americans into their causes. Each celebrity who appeared on that show could have donated just one percent of their net worth and the total would have easily exceeded the $30 million they raised.

Further, many of the pre-taped segments seemed shallow. So Simon helps get the dying African woman into a car to go to the hospital? Please. Could he possibly do something more than that to really make a difference? One segment started by asking some celebs how many funerals they had attended. Their answeres were obviously canned--six, five, etc. Well, I'm not that old and I've probably been to thirty or forty funerals in my life. Besides, who remembers exactly how many funerals they have been to?

The whole show felt as if it was slapped together in a few hours and the audience was manipulated into watching the whole thing for something that never came anyway.

Posted at 11:27AM on Apr 27th 2007 by tommy

45. this isnt about them its about the children around the world
i thought the show was great and it served the very purpose of raising money
im sure that pink and gwen understand that if they dont oh well

Posted at 1:52PM on Apr 27th 2007 by melissa